Skip to content
Read • Question • ConnectAnthony’s notes & researchReturn with a new question
Anthony’s NotesA personal field guide
From the notebook

Dangerous Liberty LIVE Ep172 - Cult Expert Keri Smith: Is the Candace Owens Cult Real?

Based on the transcript provided, the speaker analyzing Candace Owens is Gary (the host of the _Dangerous Liberty_podcast), along with his guest Matt Cardio. Keri Smith does not appear in this text, but Gary explicitly describes Owens’ audience dynamics using cult-like terminology (e.g., “cult following,” “drinking the Kool-Aid,” “turned into a religion”).
Here are the specific “cult-style” manipulation techniques Gary and Matt describe Owens using to maintain control over her audience:

1. Information Control (The “Echo Chamber”)

Gary describes how Owens creates a self-sealing environment where outside information is automatically rejected.

  • The Technique: Conditioning followers to view contradictory facts as attacks rather than evidence.
  • Transcript Evidence: Gary notes, “When somebody ends up stating, ‘you will never convince me’… you need to end that conversation because they don’t have an open mind.” He compares it to a weather report: “Candace Owens says, ‘No, it’s not raining outside.’ You go outside, you’re standing there getting soaked, and you’re like, ‘Candace is right.‘“

2. Demonization of Outsiders and “Apostates”

Owens is described as ruthlessly attacking anyone who contradicts her narrative, even if they are victims or innocent bystanders.

  • The Technique: Labeling critics or witnesses as “bad actors,” “shills,” or morally corrupt to discredit their testimony without addressing their evidence.
  • Transcript Evidence: Gary highlights the attacks on Charlie Kirk’s widow (“How dare you go after that woman?”) and the security team (“They start character assassination to them… you’re not saying what I want you to say… so you are some sort of bad actor”).

3. “Just Asking Questions” (Weaponized Ambiguity)

Gary identifies this as a method to implant false ideas while maintaining plausible deniability.

  • The Technique: Framing severe accusations (like murder) as innocent inquiries to avoid accountability while leading the audience to a specific, radical conclusion.
  • Transcript Evidence: “When you are accusing people of murder through a question, it’s not asking questions… you’re being completely dishonest.” Gary notes that this allows her to introduce “new characters” and wild theories (like Egyptian planes or the French Foreign Legion) without evidence.

4. Moving the Goalposts (Unfalsifiability)

Owens is described as constantly shifting the narrative so that she can never be pinned down or proven wrong.

  • The Technique: When one conspiracy theory is debunked (e.g., the “Lance Twigs” theory), she immediately pivots to a new, more complex one without acknowledging the error or apologizing.
  • Transcript Evidence: Gary points out she has moved from blaming specific individuals to “TPUSA,” then to “Israel,” then “Egyptian planes,” and finally the “French Foreign Legion.” He notes, “She paints a picture for you without ever even considering other options… It’s dishonesty through omission.”

5. Reality Distortion (Gaslighting)

Gary provides examples of Owens altering the perception of reality to fit the narrative, making her followers doubt their own eyes.

  • The Technique: Using manipulated media or false context to make innocent actions look nefarious.
  • Transcript Evidence: Gary describes how a video of security guards “grimacing” at a traumatic scene was presented as them “smiling and joking,” tricking the audience into seeing “something that doesn’t even exist.”

6. Exploiting “Mindless Lemmings” (Demand for Purity)

The speakers describe the audience as having surrendered their critical faculties to the leader.

  • The Technique: Encouraging followers to reject “nuance” or “technical explanations” (like ballistics) in favor of simple, emotionally satisfying conspiracies.
  • Transcript Evidence: “It has turned into a religion for you… deciding to believe that not only without evidence, but in spite of evidence.” Gary calls this a “complete lack of mental discipline” where followers want “confirmation bias” rather than truth.

7. Extortion of Authority

  • The Technique: Demanding that authorities prove a negative or release restricted evidence (like autopsy reports or call logs during an active investigation), and then claiming the absence of this illegal release is proof of a cover-up.
  • Transcript Evidence: “She will allege something and then say, ‘Look, all they got to do is give me the evidence to prove me wrong.’… attempting to extort people for information.”

Based on your request, I have researched the specific manipulation and cult-style tactics identified in the transcript to provide a deeper, more academic explanation.
The speakers in your transcript, Gary and Matt, are describing behaviors that align closely with established models of high-control groups, specifically Steven Hassan’s BITE Model (Behavior, Information, Thought, and Emotional control) and Robert Jay Lifton’s Eight Criteria for Thought Reform.
Here is a more complete explanation of these tactics, linking the events in the transcript to their psychological definitions.

1. Information Control (The BITE Model)

In the transcript, Gary describes how the subject’s audience is conditioned to reject any “rain” (facts) that contradicts the leader’s report.

  • The Academic Concept: This is a core component of the BITE Model. It involves “milieu control”—controlling the environment and communication. By filtering out valid outside information and labeling it as “fake” or “attacks,” a leader creates a closed system where their word is the only source of truth.
  • How it works here: The transcript highlights that followers are trained to view contradictory evidence not as data to be analyzed, but as a personal attack on the leader. This effectively immunizes the leader from criticism because the follower’s brain is trained to reject the “virus” of outside facts before they can take root.

2. “Dispensing of Existence” (Demonization of Outsiders)

Gary notes that anyone who questions the narrative—even victims like Charlie Kirk’s widow—is attacked or treated as a “bad actor.”

  • The Academic Concept: Robert Jay Lifton calls this “Dispensing of Existence.” It is the idea that the group has the prerogative to decide who has the “right” to exist or be heard. Those outside the group (or those who leave/criticize it) are not just “wrong”; they are viewed as non-persons, evil, or fundamentally illegitimate.
  • How it works here: By turning critics into “enemies” or “shills,” the leader dehumanizes them. This allows the audience to bypass their natural empathy. They don’t have to feel bad about attacking a widow if they have been convinced she is part of a “deep state” plot.

3. JAQing Off (“Just Asking Questions”)

The transcript describes the subject accusing people of murder by “just asking questions” to avoid accountability.

  • The Academic Concept: In media studies and logic, this is known as “JAQing off” (a play on “jacking off”). It is a bad-faith argumentation tactic where a person asks leading questions—often based on wild or debunked premises—to plant a false narrative without accepting the burden of proof. It exploits the audience’s open-mindedness.
  • How it works here: It allows the manipulator to spread disinformation while maintaining plausible deniability (“I never said he was a murderer; I just asked why he was there”). It forces the victim to disprove a negative, which is often impossible, leaving the suspicion to linger permanently.

4. Moving the Goalposts (Unfalsifiability)

Gary points out that every time a theory (like “Lance Twigs”) is debunked, the subject pivots to a new one (like “French Foreign Legion”) without acknowledging the error.

  • The Academic Concept: This is the Moving the Goalposts logical fallacy. In a cultic context, it ensures the leader is never wrong. The narrative is “unfalsifiable”—no amount of evidence can prove it false because the parameters for proof are constantly changed.
  • How it works here: It creates an exhausting cycle for critics. By the time you debunk the “Egyptian plane” theory, the leader has already moved the audience to the “drone with lasers” theory. The audience never has time to process the failure of the first prediction before being swept up in the excitement of the next one.

5. Gaslighting (Reality Distortion)

The transcript mentions the subject showing a video of security guards “grimacing” but telling the audience they are “smiling and laughing,” which the audience then believes.

  • The Academic Concept: Gaslighting is a form of psychological abuse where the manipulator forces the victim to question their own perception of reality. Over time, the victim stops trusting their own eyes and ears and relies entirely on the manipulator’s interpretation of the world.
  • How it works here: This is a power move. By making the audience agree with a blatant lie (seeing smiles where there are none), the leader breaks down their independent cognitive faculties. It binds the follower to the leader because agreeing with the lie becomes a test of loyalty.

6. Demand for Purity

Gary mentions that followers must believe every part of the conspiracy, and questioning one part makes you an “outsider.”

  • The Academic Concept: Lifton calls this the “Demand for Purity.” The world is divided sharply into pure (the group/leader) and impure (everyone else). There is no room for nuance. Guilt and shame are used to control members who might have “impure” thoughts (doubts).
  • How it works here: It creates a high-pressure environment where “doubt” is equated with “sin.” Followers are terrified of being labeled a “shill” or a “normie,” so they perform exaggerated displays of loyalty and agreement to signal their purity to the group.

7. Shifting the Burden of Proof

The subject demands the FBI or other agencies “prove her wrong” regarding her wild theories.

  • The Academic Concept: This is the Reversal of Burden of Proof (or Onus Probandi). In logic, the person making the claim (e.g., “The French Foreign Legion did it”) must provide the evidence. Shifting the burden requires the accused to prove their innocence, which is logically fallacious and often impossible (proving a negative).
  • How it works here: It is an “extortion of authority.” It allows the leader to claim victory by default. If the FBI doesn’t release a classified autopsy report to a podcaster (which they legally can’t), the leader claims this “silence” is proof of a cover-up.
    … Cult Deprogramming & The BITE Model
    This video features Dr. Steven Hassan, the creator of the BITE model referenced above, explaining how these specific tactics are used to manipulate people and how to help those who have fallen victim to them.

Content

In Ep172 I’ll be talking with cult expert Keri Smith and discussing the tactics Candace Owens uses to convince millions of her followers of false narratives. We’ll also talk about the strange behaviour of her followers and their resistance to evidence that they are being lied to.

Join us every Wednesday at 8pm for our LIVE Dangerous Liberty Podcast here on YouTube and Rumble.

You can support the channel by becoming a member: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCWCLMT5T\_ondX8VyCdCjOLQ/join

Join our Free Newsletter for upcoming events, exclusive sales and more.
https://paramounttactical.substack.com/

Keri Smith is the host of Deprogrammed, a show about leaving cults. She spent over 20 years in the Woke Cult after being indoctrinated at Duke University and bringing the ideology into her work with comedians in TV and film. She uses Deprogrammed to help pull people out of the cult, and counsel loved ones of those lost to it.

Follow Keri:
X: https://x.com/RealKeriSmith
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@RealKeriSmith
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/realkerismith/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/keri.smith.garcia

Follow us:
Twitter: https://twitter.com/paramounttactcl/
Facebook Page https://www.facebook.com/ParamountTactical
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/paramount\_tactical/
Rumble: https://rumble.com/c/ParamountTactical

Gary Melton is a former U.S. Army Special Forces Green Beret, Weapons Sergeant, and Sniper Team Leader with 4 combat tours. He has worked full time as a Unit Chief and Special Tactics Instructor at a federal agency, and is the owner and Lead Instructor for Paramount Tactical Solutions.

Paramount Tactical Solutions is staffed by Special Operations veterans and cadre that are required to have high level operational experience and to have worked full time as a tactical instructor for Federal Law Enforcement and/or the military. Paramount specializes in training Military and LE units as well as civilians in firearms, tactics, security, and tactical medicine.

🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 https://streamyard.com/pal/d/5725778494095360