Skip to content
Read • Question • ConnectAnthony’s notes & researchReturn with a new question
Anthony’s NotesA personal field guide
From the notebook

Violence Against Jews Before 1948

⬅️ Key Arguments (MOC) · Timeline: 3000BCE-1800 · 1800-1899 · 1900-1948 · Related: Massacres & War Crimes · Colonizers · Nakba · Radicalization

One-line rebuttal

“The Palestinians welcomed the Jews peacefully and it all started in 1948” is false. Jews were attacked, massacred, and pogromed in the land for centuries before Israel existed — long before any state, occupation, settlement, or refugee. The violence predates every grievance later used to explain it.

The claim

“Muslims and Jews lived in peace; there was no violence against Jews before 1948; the conflict only began when Israel was created / with the Nakba.”

Notebook page (B5)

Misc/Documents/Violence Against Jews Before 1948 - B5 Polemic.png
Polemic page against “it all started in 1948, with the occupation”: evidence ladder from 1834 to November 1947, the turn, concessions, traps and ripostes, a thirty-second version and the closing line. Source: Attachment (file not included in this release).

📅 Summary — The Record Before There Was a State

The events below all happened before 14 May 1948 — before Israel, before the “occupation,” before settlements, before the refugee problem. The intensity of anti-Jewish violence rose with Jewish immigration and British protection of it, and its stated motive was consistently religious and anti-Zionist — not a reaction to a state that did not yet exist.

YearEventJewish tollNote
1517Hebron pogromdozens killed/raped, community lootedOttoman conquest → 3000BCE-1800 > ^1517heb
1834Looting of Safedmass rape, looting, weeks of terrorDuring the Peasants’ Revolt → 1800-1899 > ^77fa0c
1834Battle of Hebron7 men + 5 girls killed”Worse than Safed” → 1800-1899 > ^cff289
1838Druze attack on Safed3 days of plunder→ 1800-1899 > ^a1d88a
1920Nebi Musa / Jerusalem riots5 killedIncited by al-Husseini → 1900-1948 > ^19f9a8
1921Jaffa riots47 killed→ 1900-1948 > ^3ffcd6
1929Palestine riots133 killedSparked by Western Wall lie → 1900-1948
1929Hebron Massacre67–69 killedRape, torture, mutilation → 1900-1948 > ^1e47bc
1936–39Arab Revolt~500 killedDeclared a jihad → 1900-1948 > ^1718e8
1939White Paper(political)Arab violence → doors shut on Jews fleeing Hitler

🕌 1517 — Hebron Pogrom

As Ottoman forces displaced the Mamluks, the Jews of Hebron were subjected to a pogrom — killings, rapes, and the looting of Jewish homes. This is four centuries before political Zionism and shows anti-Jewish violence in the land long predates any modern national conflict.

📖 The Farhud, 1941 — On Democracies and Death Cults (p.28)

Seven years before Israel existed, a Nazi-inspired pogrom in Baghdad murdered ~600 Iraqi Jews — a community present since Babylon. A red hand was painted on Jewish homes; crowds shouted “Cutal al yehud” (“Slaughter the Jews”). A survivor watched them cut off and parade a woman’s breast. Anti-Jewish mass violence in the region long predates any Israeli policy. → On Democracies and Death Cults

🔥 1834 — Safed & Hebron (Ottoman era)

During the Peasants’ Revolt against Egyptian rule:

  • Looting of Safed — after a Muslim cleric, Muhammad Damoor, prophesied “true believers would rise up in just wrath against the Jews,” a mob spent weeks raping, looting, and terrorizing the Jewish community. → 1800-1899 > ^77fa0c · 📚 Wikipedia
  • Battle of Hebron — seven Jewish men and five girls killed; synagogues desecrated, homes ransacked. An eyewitness said it was worse than Safed. → 1800-1899 > ^cff289 · 📚 Wikipedia
  • 1838 Druze attack on Safed — three more days of plunder and desecration. → 1800-1899 > ^a1d88a

⚔️ 1920–1921 — The Mandate Riots Begin

  • 1920 Nebi Musa / Jerusalem riots — incited by Haj Amin al-Husseini’s inflammatory speech; the pattern of pogrom-by-incitement is established. → 1900-1948 > ^19f9a8
  • 1921 Jaffa riots — 47 Jews killed; a British commission found the cause was “hostility to the Jews… connected with Jewish immigration.” → 1900-1948 > ^3ffcd6 · 📚 Wikipedia

🕍 1929 — The Western Wall Riots & Hebron Massacre

Sparked by a false rumor that Jews were seizing the Temple Mount / Al-Aqsa:

  • 1929 Palestine riots — 133 Jews killed, 339 wounded across the country.
  • Hebron Massacre (24 Aug 1929) — Arab mobs murdered 67–69 Jews, with documented rape, torture, and mutilation, ending Hebron’s ancient Jewish community. This was 19 years before Israel existed. → 1900-1948 > ^1e47bc · 📚 Wikipedia · 📚 1929 Palestine riots

🛑 1936–1939 — The Arab Revolt (a jihad, not a border dispute)

A three-year uprising against Jewish immigration and British rule. Contemporary observers — including Christian clergy testifying before the Peel Commission — described it as a “Holy War against a Christian Mandate and against Christian people as well as against the Jews.” The Arab Higher Committee framed it in the language of jihad; clerics preached that “anyone who killed a land seller would reside in paradise.” ~500 Jews were killed.

📜 1939 — The White Paper: Arab Violence Slammed the Door on Refugees

The revolt worked. To pacify the Arabs on the eve of WWII, Britain issued the 1939 White Paper, which:

  • Capped Jewish immigration at 75,000 over five years, with any further entry requiring Arab consent (which would never come);
  • Severely curbed Jewish land purchases.

The result: as Hitler began the Holocaust, the gates of the one refuge were shut — because Arab violence and rioting had made Jewish immigration too costly for Britain. → 1900-1948 > 1939 May: White Paper of 1939 · 📚 White Paper of 1939 — Wikipedia

1947 October: Azzam Pasha and prewar leadership rhetoric

Before the partition vote — Arab League secretary-general Azzam Pasha

In a reported interview published 11 October 1947, Azzam anticipated a “war of extermination and momentous massacre,” a religiously motivated volunteer struggle, and opportunities for plunder. He predicted eventual Arab victory while calling the fight defensive. Read the corrected excerpts with his opening wish to avoid war and his closing self-defense claim: quotation, attribution, and omissions.

Argument use: violent opposition to a projected Jewish state was publicly articulated by a senior Arab official before Israel existed. This is evidence of leadership rhetoric and a basis for understanding Jewish threat perceptions, not a documented massacre event, a survey of all Arabs, or proof of every army’s operational intent. The source note distinguishes the genocidal-threat reading from the conditional-warning reading. Contemporary source trail and date · debate card

🖼️ The Viral “22 Attacks Before 1948” List — Annotated

A graphic circulating as “a non-exhaustive list of attacks committed against Jewish people in the Land of Israel before 1948” lists 22 events. The chronology it asserts is substantially sound — but it contains at least two errors and a few items that won’t survive a hostile cross-examination. Use the verified column, not the graphic.

Fix these before citing the graphic

  • “1884 Hebron pogrom” is a typo for 1834. There was no notable 1884 Hebron pogrom; the Hebron attack belongs to the same 1834 Egyptian-rule upheaval as the Safed looting. (This note has it right above.)
  • “1939 Haifa Oil Refinery massacre” is almost certainly misdated. The refinery massacre on record is 30 December 1947 — ~39 Jewish workers killed by Arab co-workers following an Irgun bombing. Treat the 1939 date as unverified.
  • “1937 Har Haruach ambush” — unverified. Not corroborated in this vault or from memory; don’t cite until sourced.
  • The list also runs 1936 out of order — the Anabta shooting (15 Apr) preceded and triggered the Jaffa riots (19 Apr).
#EventStatusIn vault?
11517 Hebron pogrom✅ solid✅ section above · 3000BCE-1800 > ^1517heb
21517 Safed pogrom✅ solid⚠️ link-only → List of Islamic Pogroms from 500 years before State of Israel until 1948
31660 Safed destruction⚠️ contested scale⚠️ link-only
41660 Tiberias destruction✅ solid⚠️ link-only · @1660DestructionTiberias2024
51834 Hebron pogrom (graphic says 1884)✅ solid✅ above · @BattleHebron2024
61834 Safed pogrom✅ solid✅ above · @1834LootingSafed2024
71838 Safed riot✅ solid✅ above
81920 Nebi Musa riots✅ solid✅ above · @1920NebiMusa2024
91920 Battle of Tel Hai⚠️ weakest item✅ 1900-1948 · @BattleTelHai2024
101921 Jaffa riots✅ solid✅ above · @JaffaRiots2024
111921 Haifa riots✅ solid❌ new below
121929 Motza massacre✅ solid❌ new below
131929 Hebron massacre✅ solid✅ above · @1929HebronMassacre2024
141929 Safed massacre✅ solid❌ new below
151931 Black Hand killings✅ solid❌ new below
161932 Black Hand killings✅ solid❌ new below
171936 Jaffa riots✅ solid⚠️ only as “Arab Revolt”
181936 Anabta shooting✅ solid❌ new below
191937 Har Haruach ambush❓ unverified❌
201938 Tiberias massacre✅ solid❌ new below · @1938TiberiasMassacre2024
211939 Haifa oil refinery massacre❌ misdated (1947)❌
221947 Jerusalem road killings✅ solid⚠️ partial

➕ The Events This Note Was Missing

1517 — Safed pogrom. The companion to the Hebron attack of the same year: as Ottoman forces displaced the Mamluks, the resulting power vacuum was used to plunder Safed’s Jewish quarter, with killings and expulsion. Debate value is identical to 1517 Hebron — four centuries before political Zionism existed.

1660 — Destruction of Tiberias and Safed. Both Jewish communities were wiped out during Druze factional warfare in the Galilee; Tiberias was left essentially desolate for decades, and its Jewish community did not meaningfully return until the 1740s.

Use with precision

These were not targeted anti-Jewish pogroms in the way 1929 was — they were general regional lawlessness that consumed the Jewish communities living in it. That is still fatal to “Jews lived peacefully under Muslim rule until Zionism,” because it shows how defenceless a stateless minority was — which is Zionism’s actual argument. But don’t call them pogroms in a debate; call them what they were. Safed’s 1660 destruction in particular is disputed among historians as to scale.

1921 — Haifa riots. Part of the same May 1921 country-wide outbreak as the Jaffa riots, driven by the same stated grievance: Jewish immigration. Jaffa was far deadlier (47 dead), which is why Haifa is usually folded into “the 1921 riots.”

1929 — Motza massacre (24 August 1929, during the country-wide riots). Residents of the neighbouring Arab village attacked the Maklef family’s house in Motza, west of Jerusalem, killing the parents and three of the children. Mordechai Maklef survived by escaping through a window — he later became the IDF’s third Chief of Staff. Worth knowing precisely because it wasn’t in a contested holy city: Motza was a small farming settlement, and the family was known to its attackers.

1929 — Safed massacre (29 August 1929). Roughly 18–20 Jews killed, with the Jewish quarter burned and looted. This is the event the current note buried inside the aggregate “133 killed” figure. Pair it with Hebron: the same week, the same incitement, and in both cases the victims were the old, non-Zionist religious communities — Jews who had been there for centuries and had nothing to do with the Zionist movement. That detail dismantles “this was resistance to Zionist settlers.”

1931 & 1932 — the Black Hand killings. The Black Hand (al-Kaff al-Aswad) was the armed cell of Sheikh Izz ad-Din al-Qassam — the preacher whose name Hamas later took for its military wing, the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades. Its campaign of small-scale murders of Jewish civilians ran through the early 1930s, including the killings at Yagur (1931) and the grenade attack on a home in Nahalal (December 1932), which killed a father and his son.

Why these two lines matter more than their body count

They establish that organised, religiously-framed terrorism against Jewish civilians predates the Arab Revolt, the 1947 partition vote, Israel, and the occupation by decades — and that today’s most prominent armed Islamist faction consciously names itself after the man who ran it. → Hamas · Radicalization

1936 — Anabta shooting (15 April 1936). Gunmen stopped traffic near Anabta, singled out Jewish drivers and shot them; Israel Khazan died. This is the trigger event of the entire Arab Revolt — the retaliation and counter-retaliation that followed within days produced the Jaffa riots (19 April) and then three years of revolt. Useful because it’s the precise causal starting point that “1936–39” flattens.

1938 — Tiberias massacre (2 October 1938). During the revolt, an armed band entered Tiberias and killed 19 Jews, of whom 11 were children, in a night attack on homes and the Jewish quarter. One of the clearest cases in the whole record of deliberate targeting of children, and it happened ten years before Israel existed.

1947 — the Jerusalem road killings. From the day after the 29 November 1947 partition vote, Arab irregulars began ambushing traffic on the roads to Jerusalem — starting with the Jaffa–Jerusalem bus ambush of 30 November — escalating into the systematic convoy war that besieged Jewish Jerusalem and starved it through spring 1948. Note the sequencing for debate: this began immediately after the Jewish side accepted partition and before Israel declared independence, i.e. the war on the Jewish state began before the state did. → 1900-1948 · Peace Offers

🧠 What the list actually proves (and what it doesn’t)

The strongest form of the argument

Don’t argue “22 attacks, therefore they’re the aggressors.” Argue the chronological split:

  • Items 1–7 (1517–1838) predate political Zionism entirely. No state, no settlements, no immigration wave, no Balfour. They cannot be a reaction to Zionism, because Zionism did not exist. What they show is what happened to Jews as a stateless, unarmed, tolerated-at-best minority — which is the premise Zionism was built on. → Zionism
  • Items 8–22 (1920–1947) predate Israel, the occupation, the settlements, and the refugees. They track Jewish immigration and British protection of it, and their stated motive was rejection of Jewish presence and sovereignty — not any policy of a state that did not yet exist.

Weakest links to drop if challenged: Tel Hai (an armed clash in a French-Syrian war zone, not a pogrom), the 1660 events (regional lawlessness, not targeted pogroms), and the two erroneous entries. Concede those three cheerfully and the remaining seventeen are untouched — which is a much stronger position than defending a graphic you didn’t fact-check.

🎯 Why This Matters (debate use)

  1. The chronology destroys the “it started in 1948 / with the occupation” narrative. Every “root cause” cited (state, occupation, settlements, refugees, blockade) postdates decades of anti-Jewish violence.
  2. The motive was consistent and stated openly — religious and anti-Zionist rejection of any Jewish presence/sovereignty, not a response to specific Israeli policy. → Radicalization · Colonizers
  3. Rioting was a deliberate, rewarded strategy. The British repeatedly responded to Arab violence by restricting Jews — teaching that violence pays. See 1900-1948: “The Arabs found rioting to be a very effective political tool because the British… encouraged more outbreaks of violence.”
  4. It was lethal on the eve of the Holocaust — Arab pressure closed Palestine to Jews precisely when they had nowhere else to go. → Zionism

🔗 See Also